We booked this villa for our honeymoon and flew in from the UK for our first trip to the USVI, so "getting it just right" was VERY important! Words cannot describe how beautiful this villa is. The views of Fish Bay and beyond are incredible and even better than pictures provided online. This place is casual interiors, modern amenities, spacious and well-appointed. I loved the high ceilings. Both ensuite bedrooms were of equal size and private with separate sitting rooms and balconies, and therefore made this villa great for sharing with family or another couple, as we did.
The fans and screened windows on all sides along with the elevation kept a nice breeze flowing throughout, and the bedrooms A/C's and pool were very welcome while sleeping/sunning on the deck. It felt like an approximate 20 min drive to Cruz Bay (remote enough to feel peaceful, but convenient enough to amenities and access to ferry and market).
The drive is steep, and 4WD is a must, but the roads are also paved all the way to the driveway, so you never feel uneasy. The property manager, Mary, was helpful and professional, and met us at the ferry dock to lead us straight to our door (thank goodness, as the signage in that area is vague). The owners provided plenty of information and recommendations, and were expeditious in answering emails and phone calls. We travel frequently all over Europe, etc., and know a great place when we see it. Sea Turtle Villa exceeded our expectations.