We stayed at Kallaloo twice and loved it. The only reason we haven't stayed 3, 4, and 5 times is our son is too young. As soon as he reaches the minimum age, we will be back at that location.
We stayed in Hawknest last fall and loved it. We specifically booked it so that we could be close to Gibney and Hawsnest. Would definitely book it again.
Nothingtolose,you sound like my wife!No air...forget it!Now as for myself;I would sleep on the ground next to a donkey and be as happy as a lark just knowing I was on mt favorite island!Parafins