We are staying in Coral Bay....I am a bit afraid but I am confident that it will feel like a whole new vacation for us!
We had a tough time deciding on a villa but after emails and PM's and everyone's advice, I think that we picked a good one! (I don't like to share where we are staying on a public board, so...)
I am impressed that you don't give out your rental location! There are so many of us that say where and when we are staying. Have you had a bad experience and no longer share your info?
I stopped publicizing my rental villa a few trips ago.
The internet is a funny place with many people that are not what they seem, I don't need them to know where I am staying and when...and I also don't need the unsolicited opinions about the villa we choose after we paid the deposit
Second timer here (come Feb), so I'm no expert.....stayed one week in Coral Bay and one week in Cruz Bay (the first time)...loved them both. You will be pleased, I'm sure. It's St.John after all
We really love Coral bay. No sunsets but the sunrises are equal, an we are early risers. It is a bit of a drive to many of the places, but we found our selves driving to Coral Bay as much or more as we drove to Cruz Bay trips past! We love the views and the quiet!