I didn't realize that they were higher than the others. They do have parking in town so maybe that is why? I've rented from them twice, both times we got newer jeeps that were in great condition.
It's like looking in your soup and finding a whole different alphabet.
We rented a 2-door Jeep from them last year and are renting another 2 weeks from today. We found little or no difference between them and their comptetiton in terms of price. We were very pleased with their Jeep and service. Are you sure you are comparing apples to apples?
We are renting a Dodge Durango. Our usual, Conrad, didn't have it available for our time frame, STJ Car Rental was $90.00 more per week than Paris, we went with Paris.
I chose Courtesy over St. John Car Rental for the same reason..need a 7 passenger vehicle (rented a Ford Explorer) and it is $120 less with Courtesy. They also have a lot in town, I believe. This is for a 2012 trip and I have no first and experience...yet:)