We are considering a post wedding celebration in St. John next spring via a dinner sunset cruise. We have heard recommendations about Scubadu Catamaran and Joe Mellen. Any forum feedback?
My husband and I always sail with Captain Joe whenever we visit St. John. We haven't done the dinner cruise but if its anything like his day sail (which includes lunch) you will have a great time. Joe is a great chef! You can't go wrong. If you do decide tell Joe, Susan and Ted from NJ say hello!
I also highly recommend the Scubadu. Joe is an excellent host and cook. I haven't had his dinners but if his lunches are any indication I am certain your dinner would be excellent. I think your idea is a perfect way to celebrate.