So,- Which is your favorite beach, and why?

Travel discussion for St. John
lavender
Posts: 123
Joined: Tue Aug 08, 2006 7:16 am
Location: Canandaigua, NY

Post by lavender »

This time we went to Gibney and I think that is my new favorite - hadn't been there before and we loved it - soft sand, nice views, lovely swimming, calm waters, excellent palms for shade - lovely. I also am very partial to Trunk - an absolutely gorgeous beach and I love the peaceful snorkeling there.
Jumbiegirl
Posts: 301
Joined: Mon Aug 07, 2006 8:30 pm
Location: Holland, MI

Post by Jumbiegirl »

Jumbie - hence the screen name. I love looking around the little tide pool looking for creatures. The coral used to be spectacular here and then all but disappeared - still interesting things to snorkel around yet. Love that it's quiet and has lots of shade if needed.
Trip #14 comes June 11, 2015!!
User avatar
sea-nile
Posts: 3761
Joined: Sun Oct 22, 2006 1:24 pm
Location: Southeast Wisconsin

Post by sea-nile »

It IS hard to limit it to one. However I will have to say Trunk, but only when it is not crowded in the early morning. I like the fact that it is #1 Beautiful, #2- has facilities and food, #3 life guards, #4 pretty good snorleking, #5 the first beach I hit when visiting STJ for the first time.
Maho is great too.

When I brought the whole family we each had a favorite.
Daughter- Cinnamom- more guys
Son- Maho- snorkeling and turtles
Husband- Waterlemon- the snorkeling and hike
User avatar
waterguy
Posts: 4307
Joined: Wed Aug 09, 2006 3:06 pm
Location: Green Bay ,WI

Post by waterguy »

Hawksnest for personal reasons
Maho for my lazy days
Honeymoon? saloman when I want that oh moment
Tom
User avatar
lark22
Posts: 415
Joined: Mon Aug 14, 2006 11:52 pm
Location: Boston

Post by lark22 »

Francis will always have a dear place in my heart -- it's the very first beach we stepped foot on, ten minutes after arriving at our villa on our first trip to STJ. Instant love.
jimg20
Posts: 1840
Joined: Mon May 28, 2007 11:43 am
Location: Fayetteville, AR

Post by jimg20 »

Our first STJ beach, like many of you, was Trunk. It is a great beach, we enjoyed it that day and it was the one that got us hooked on STJ. It is, however sometimes crowded and overused. When the ships are in it's a bit of a problem.

Our current favorite beach is Hawksnest. The parking is close without feeling like you have a bumper directly behind you. The facilities are a plus. The main reason is that the water, coral, marine life, view and atmosphere are exactly what we think a tropical beach should be. Put me there after a great two-tank dive with a sandwich from Deli Grotto and I am set.

A week from right now I may have another choice for the number one beach; but for today, this is it.

JIM

PS We are about 48 hours from stowing our tray tables and placing our seats in their upright and most uncomfortable position. Not that I'm counting or anything.
Man it's like some dream we live down here....

Image
User avatar
sea-nile
Posts: 3761
Joined: Sun Oct 22, 2006 1:24 pm
Location: Southeast Wisconsin

Post by sea-nile »

Quote: Our current favorite beach is Hawksnest. The parking is close without feeling like you have a bumper directly behind you. The facilities are a plus. The main reason is that the water, coral, marine life, view and atmosphere are exactly what we think a tropical beach should be. Put me there after a great two-tank dive with a sandwich from Deli Grotto and I am set.

A week from right now I may have another choice for the number one beach; but for today, this is it.

JIM


PS We are about 48 hours from stowing our tray tables and placing our seats in their upright and most uncomfortable position. Not that I'm counting or anything.[/quote]




Jim I have to agree with you about Hawksnest for snorkeling. I enjoyed going there with you and Diana.
You two have fun! I know that you will!
54b
Posts: 537
Joined: Thu Jun 04, 2009 3:40 pm
Location: Dallas, TX

Post by 54b »

Doesn't get any better than Gibney for me too, but I'll nominate Denis up as a close second...it's a lot like Gibney, just a little tougher to get to.

in addition to having all the usual STJ beach qualities you want - soft sand, shade, good snorkeling, limited visitors, great views (Trunk is across the bay from it) - Denis also has the added bonus of not being clearly marked and doesn't seem to show up on a lot of tourist maps or guides.

So like Gibney, it has a certain "secret club" aspect going for it even though it's not really that big of a secret.
It’s not about yesterday or tomorrow...It’s about today, for come what may – Sun, rain, or hurricane – we've only time for a smile, and none for sorrow
User avatar
BillVT
Posts: 544
Joined: Tue Aug 08, 2006 5:58 am
Location: Grand Isle VT

Post by BillVT »

I'm not a big beach lay-arounder but I can understand everyone's choices. The one beach I am able to spend a lot of time at is Brown's Bay. It takes a little effort to get to, it is sandy and when I'm tired of the book I'm reading I can snorkel either the right side or left. When I get tired of that I can wander around the ruins. It is hardly ever "busy" and Skinny's is on the way home.

If the wind is up I'll settle on Francis. Although Maho is great as a wind default it is usually a little too crowded for me.
User avatar
flip-flop
Posts: 4034
Joined: Fri Aug 11, 2006 11:17 am
Location: Northern VA

Post by flip-flop »

Maho. Its the only one I ever find myself repeating in one trip. Sad, I know but true.
Image
jmq
Posts: 2373
Joined: Tue Aug 08, 2006 9:32 am
Location: NJ

Post by jmq »

VickiH wrote:Maho, under the palms beside the green building. Perfection.
Agreed.

<a href="http://www.flickr.com/photos/jmq/8799336/" title="STJ2 Maho Bay by jmq, on Flickr"><img src="http://farm1.static.flickr.com/4/8799336_3cce4e860f.jpg" width="500" height="375" alt="STJ2 Maho Bay"></a>
When we come to place where the sea and the sky collide
Throw me over the edge and let my spirit glide
User avatar
Lovermont
Posts: 1098
Joined: Thu Jan 08, 2009 5:17 pm
Location: Vermont

Post by Lovermont »

Ya know, I've been reading these posts, and with each one I'm saying to myself "yep, I love that one too," so I went back to find a list I'd made sometime ago, listing all the reasons I love so many places on STJ. Here's my list:
Lovermont wrote:There was a topic on the "other forum" regarding Trunk Bay, and whether or not it was a beach worthy of a visit from an overseas "beach lover". There were many replies singing the praises of beaches other than Trunk, and it got me thinking about giving awards to the beaches of St. John.

Feel free to dispute my list or add your own awards. Let's face it, every beach on STJ is special in some way.

St. John Beach Oscars

The winner of “Most Beautiful Beach from a lookout, but do I really need to pay the $4 to hang out with cruise ship passengers” is – Trunk

The winner of “I’d like a beach with facilities so that I can change into my swimsuit and perhaps chill awhile and eat my lunch and enjoy the view” is – Hawksnest

The winner of “Wow, am I glad I discovered this beach; I will be back” is Denis

The winner of “Beach that’s easiest to get to directly from the road (and takes my breath away)” is – Maho

The winner of “Amazing glass water and beautiful sailboats moored right in front of me” is – Francis

The winner of “The trip getting there is half of the fun” is – Little Lameshur

The winner of “I’ll keep this on my list for a great snorkel” is – A TIE! Blue Cobblestone and Haulover

The winner of “I’d like a beach lounger and an order of Conch Fritters please” is – Vie’s beach/Hansen Beach

The winner of “I feel like renting a kayak and discovering that Cay over there” is – Cinnamon Bay

The winner of “It’s raining on the north shore, where do we go now” is – Salt Pond

The winner of “I’m tired of beautiful white sand, I want crashing waves” is – Drunk Bay

The winner of “I’d like to have some fantastic ruins with my beach, with a side of turtles and starfish” is – Waterlemon

The winner of “I’m staying in Cruz Bay, and I’d like to walk to a beach” is – A walk to Salomon and Honeymoon
Image
surfnh
Posts: 461
Joined: Thu Jan 14, 2010 8:43 pm
Location: Hollis, NH

Post by surfnh »

lsugolfer wrote:Snorkeling: Lameshur
Beach bum: Francis
Views/Water: Trunk
I 2nd this one...
Image
User avatar
mahojim
Posts: 2079
Joined: Mon May 12, 2008 6:29 pm
Location: NJ

Post by mahojim »

Don't get me wrong, ya'll!
We spent most of our time on Maho. That place is just magic to me.
I'd been to Gibney before, briefly; just walked down & checked it out.
This past trip we spent the better part of a day on Gibney. Incredible, no doubt.
Just sitting there with a chilly drink, and splashing around was gorgeous.
I could do without the trek up & down, thus Maho is my all time favorite. Maho is better for a good snorkel too, as far as I'm concerned. Many, many wonderfully delicious memories...
Smiles-
MJ
Image
dctac
Posts: 200
Joined: Sun May 17, 2009 11:03 am
Location: Tip of SJ

Post by dctac »

Hmmmm.... I haven't been to gibney yet. I think it'll be next feb. But I know my favorite Beach is the next one I chill on.....
Post Reply