Caribbean Wings- BVI Airlines is advertising a San Juan to Anegada round trip for better than the charter rate. With the AA direct flight from DC to SJU I could be on Anegada by 1PM the day I leave. That's faster then my best route to STJ!!
Ahh, but then there's deeper question: Flash of Beauty or Big Bamboo? There's something extra cool about watching the kid fetching your lobster from the pen after you place your order at Big Bamboo!