usvi-on-line
Operation:"Stop the fish worm"
I always think this topic is so interesting because of the gamut of emotions that are attached to it. I don't think it’s one about law but of respect and common courtesy. I personally have no problem with nudity on the beach but have never got nekkid on a beach in STJ. Not because it’s a law (Lord knows we all break them) but because of respect for others who may not be comfortable with it. I certainly would hate to know I made someone feel so uncomfortable that they left an area because of something I did.
I relate this topic to the one of smoking. I smoke…but I don’t smoke when around others who do not like it. Even in outside areas where smoking is allowed, I am extremely careful not to smoke when others will be affected by my smoke. It comes down to being courteous.
I have enough respect for others that I don’t push my beliefs on them and I expect that same in return. I think if everyone just cared a little and compromised a little the world would be a much better place. Peace & Love!!!
I relate this topic to the one of smoking. I smoke…but I don’t smoke when around others who do not like it. Even in outside areas where smoking is allowed, I am extremely careful not to smoke when others will be affected by my smoke. It comes down to being courteous.
I have enough respect for others that I don’t push my beliefs on them and I expect that same in return. I think if everyone just cared a little and compromised a little the world would be a much better place. Peace & Love!!!
Nude
When in Rome do as the Romans.......
-
StJohnRuth
- Posts: 1989
- Joined: Mon Aug 07, 2006 8:42 pm
- Location: St. John, VI
This is a complex issue.
1 ) This beach is on a hiking trail prone to usage by families. Some parents were not prepared for what they would find there. I don't think these people complained about naked people lying on towels sunning themselves, but about more ostentatious behaviors.
2) For years Solomon was a laid-back place that was used mostly by locals and a few in-the-know visitors. Most people went there because they didn't have cars and could walk there (or get their dinghy there), and of course they liked getting no-tan-line tans. Everyone was pretty well behaved and respectful, and if a family with children popped out of the path, everyone did the decent thing, like laid low on their beach towel or jumped in the water. Word spread to other nearby islands and to the general tourist population and some of the people who were using the beach on a regular basis didn't really care as much about what people thought or felt, because they didn't live on St. John. The behavior wasn't good. (I will spare you the details, but it wasn't good.) People complained and the laws were enforced. Some people were unhappy, some people were glad that they could start enjoying this beautiful beach again.
This is not personal for me. I am merely trying to offer some perspective, based on my first-hand observations and conversations with many people on both sides of the issue.
If you are looking for clothing-optional experiences, I recommend renting a very private villa. Also, I think some charter-boats are happy to offer this. All you have to do is ask.
-Ruth
1 ) This beach is on a hiking trail prone to usage by families. Some parents were not prepared for what they would find there. I don't think these people complained about naked people lying on towels sunning themselves, but about more ostentatious behaviors.
2) For years Solomon was a laid-back place that was used mostly by locals and a few in-the-know visitors. Most people went there because they didn't have cars and could walk there (or get their dinghy there), and of course they liked getting no-tan-line tans. Everyone was pretty well behaved and respectful, and if a family with children popped out of the path, everyone did the decent thing, like laid low on their beach towel or jumped in the water. Word spread to other nearby islands and to the general tourist population and some of the people who were using the beach on a regular basis didn't really care as much about what people thought or felt, because they didn't live on St. John. The behavior wasn't good. (I will spare you the details, but it wasn't good.) People complained and the laws were enforced. Some people were unhappy, some people were glad that they could start enjoying this beautiful beach again.
This is not personal for me. I am merely trying to offer some perspective, based on my first-hand observations and conversations with many people on both sides of the issue.
If you are looking for clothing-optional experiences, I recommend renting a very private villa. Also, I think some charter-boats are happy to offer this. All you have to do is ask.
-Ruth