my husband would tell you Waterfront Bistro. Last year he hung out there while I went shopping, and now he can't wait to go back this year. He just told me the other night "It will be hard to not want to stop there right after we get off the ferry!"
A great margarita is elusive on STJ, if you ask me.
Pia makes a hell of a margarita, but you have to be lucky enough to know her well enough for her to share with you!
I would say Gecko Gazebo when Tyler is bartending. Plus, the show he puts on makes it taste better (not for the shy and reserved!)
Thanks X - next time on vacation you must come over for one maybe two (more than two is dangerous )
Yes my husbands "knickers off" margaritas are famous and fabulous and a margarita at On A Whim would be free in return for the next person willing to hand carry a pre-paid small bathroom waste basket from Restoration Hardware
While we were on St. John last Jan. my step-daughter (who is a bit of a foodie and lives and enjoys food and drink in New York City) said the margarita at Aqua Bistro was divine.
I love margaritas and each trip I have to sample them every where I go. Last trip it was a tie between Aqua Bistro and Caneel with a close runner up at High Tide.