I loved Island Time but it's haunted. Don't book it!!!!
I guess I'm kidding. I love this place but don't want too many people to know about it. If you book it you'll love it.
Here's another choice. Fairly new villa high up and overlooking south shore. Villa Tamarindo. 2 bedrooms, 2 baths, pool, and good views. We put friends up there in February while we stayed in a larger villa in Rendezvous Bay. www.stjohnvillarental.com has it, and probably a few other rental companies.
I will be rooting for the beloved Patriots again next year.