Jolly Diversion, Barefoot Villa or Casa de Palmas...reviews?

[2beachbums]

We have decided to stay on STJ for our next trip sometime between June - August. Both our kids want to go on the next trip so that means more $$$! Our oldest is 19 and never been to USVI(other is 9) so this may be the last "family" vacation with just the 4 of us. We have only stayed on STT in the past so we could use some input on STJ villas. So far we are deciding between Jolly Diversion, Barefoot Villa and Casa de Palmas. They have pretty good prices(need to have money for the 2 of us to come back in March 2011!). Do you have any comments on these villas? We would like 2 bedrooms and I would like an ocean view & soundtrack to sleep to! We don't mind if the roads are rough to the villa. Thanks!

[Vichuga]

I wanted to book Barefoot villa for our trip, but it was already taken for our dates. Person i spoke with about booking was running several villas on the island and told me that this villa was way underpriced. Just my 2 cents.