Don't understimate the barriers of no resort/all-inclusive hotels. If people have to use more than Expedia to book a vacation they don't know what to do.
Sea-nile & RickG - You CAN only camp on STJ, right?
There are no hotels. The moquitos are horrible. The locals are just mean. No shopping. NO GOOD BARS. No famous people (I heard Kenny moved). And the beaches, don't even get me started on how rough the water is.
Grommie --- Get a strong cup of coffee and start at the beginning, it will all make sense. We were being a little tongue in cheek and managed to confuse you.
Check the Island-O-Matic section of the article where there is a chart listing the amenities available on each of the islands. For St. John,"Beaches","Nature" & "Families" are starred as "Best of the Islands". Naturally, I agree. But there is also a column for golfing, and St. John rates a check mark for that. Did I miss something, or are they counting the miniature golf at Pastory Gardens? I can just picture the semi-pros stepping off the ferry in Cruz Bay with their golf bags asking the cabbies to take them to the nearest golf course...