We've narrowed our search for a rental to three candidates.

Can anyone provide feedback for Sea Cottage, Romance Cottage and Mountain Eyrie. Much appreciated

Thanks to all who have provided information and suggestions. Unfortunately Coconut Hill appears to be booked for March. So far I am leaning toward Windwardside and Stone Harbor or perhaps Bo Atebay or Papya Moon, but we are still open to suggestions before we narrow it down. Please provide your expe...

We looked at House of Open Arms, but unfortunately it is booked for March. This will be our second stay on St. John and so we are familiar with Coral Bay. I have been doing more research and seem to like Bo Atebay, Windwardside, Papaya Moon, and Island Cottage. Have any readers stayed at any of thes...

We are a couple seeking advice on a cottage rental in the Coral Bay area in March. We are looking for a comfortable, clean cottage, nicely furnished, with a good view. Any recommendations based on your experiences? Has anyone stayed at any of the following: Astral cottage, New Moon, Just Enough, Bo ...