We stayed at Le Virage at Point Rendezvous which is a four bedroom very new house (2005). Great area, quiet, great views, yet a few minutes to Cruz Bay. Your really do feel away from everything which we like. Le Virage is high up, with complete privacy. We are going back in May again. e-mail me if you want pictures.
ohhhhhhhh Cara Mia is on my list too! My list is long, can you tell?
I think the descrition of that one was actually what led me to the question since it says "exclusive Point Rendezvous". Is is a gated community or something?