greyhoundmom wrote:I can't address why not to stay in Coral Bay again! It feels like coming home to your small space on a small island. Driving up Seagrape Hill at the end of the day, seeing the donkeys bedded down in the fire station at dusk, looking at the boats bobbing in the bay from the pool, nirvana for me! Love the quiet, don't mind the drive to anywhere. Fish Bay, on the other hand, was a not so great memory...
Amen! Last time we did a week in Cruz Bay. It was def. closer and more convenient. We didn't have great sunsets that year, but that was weather. Coral Bay just feels cozier and I am up early, so I can catch the sunrise...Cruz Bay seems to be more expensive as well. Of course I am not sure of that. I think if I had a litte more money, I would like to try some places on the North shore. Our first stay was Maho... Maho is magic! Not really comfy, but magic!
Steve S wrote:In response to the original question, I can give three reasons-
-Sam and Jack's
-Deli Grotto
-Baked in the Sun
We like to split a big sandwich between snorkels at the beach and Coral Bay as far as I know has nothing to offer in terms of delis or sandwich shops.
Not delis, but in response... Donkey Diner, Tourist Trap, Skinnies, and Aqua Bistro! I need to try out the new Island Blues. Of course I have only been to Deli Grotto... of the other 3... Hmmmm they need to be on my new list!!!