Our group is returning to STJ in 11 days for our second visit. Last year we went to Maho, Francis and Hansen (our favs) and Trunk and Hawksnest. Also snorkeled Waterlemon.
We need sand, some shade and a restroom (no matter how primitive) for the ladies. Leaning to Salt Pond or Little Lameshur for a new experience. Staying nearer to Coral Bay on Mamey Peak.
What beach would you choose and why? Open to any and all suggestions.
Leinster Bay and walk to Waterlemon should definitely be on your list. As far as bathrooms, the start of the walk around Leinster has bathrooms. After that, you're on your own until you walk back out. Great snorkeling around Waterlemon. Just when you think you've walked far enough, beutiful open bay, sandy beach (I recommend a swim at this point), walk around a little further and Waterlemon direcly in front of you. Lots of big rocks to leave your gear on and rockhy entrance into water. Swimming over over to Waterlemon a nice paddle over 25 feet of deeper water. Snorkle from left to right around Waterlemon. Fabulous underwater. Enjoy!
I know you said your staying in Coral Bay but if you haven't tried Salomon or Honeymoon I would really like to suggest it. Plus Jumbie is not too bad either.