1st trip in Coral Bay, I need an education!

[lazylane]

We have never made reservations for Miss Lucy's Sunday brunch, we go in early December so not sure about high season. The Full Moon dinner is excellent too! We love Coral Bay and have stayed there the last few years. We call it the "country" side of the island and it is a much slower pace for sure but that's why I go there!! My favorite beaches are Lameshur, Vie's and Francis. Our favorite hang out is Island Blues for lunch, dinner or drinks or all of those!!! Shipwreck Landing and Aqua Bistro are excellent choices too. We have never tried Cafe Concordia, but it's on the list for this year. Donkey Diner can't be beat for breakfast and pizza is excellent! The views of Coral Bay harbor are great and so much activity to watch!! Enjoy!
http://www.concordiaeco-resort.com/MenuSample1

[momto3boys]

You all are making me so hungry!!

We are going to Coral Bay May and I did not think we would need reservations for anywhere. I guess we need to rethink that! They all sound so good I am not sure which should be on my must go list. I am going to keep all of this info for our first trip. It will come in handy.

[jayseadee]

I think Miss Lucy's does take reservations. There were tables set up for a couple of larger parties the day we were there.

[PA Girl]

You all are making me so hungry!!

We are going to Coral Bay May and I did not think we would need reservations for anywhere. I guess we need to rethink that! They all sound so good I am not sure which should be on my must go list. I am going to keep all of this info for our first trip. It will come in handy.

Stay tuned, I will give a full report.

I am taking "the file" home this weekend to start formulating the plan, eating out is important to my vacation experience!

[liamsaunt]

Definitely try Sweet Plantains. I've only been there once (the one time we stayed in Coral Bay) because John doesn't like to do the Cruz Bay to Coral Bay drive in the dark, but I still remember how much I liked the food and atmosphere there. I am pushing hard for our trip next summer to be based out of Coral Bay and I will admit that being able to eat at Sweet Plantains again has something to do with that!

[PA Girl]

The first night on STJ is my birthday and I am thinking we need to go to Sweet Plantains.

[Randy in MD]

Friday & Saturday nights are "Curry Night" at Sweet Plantains... My favorite nights to go there...