Sunset with boats

[St. John Lover]

Ok, I'm the contrarian one here. I actually like #2 better because the orange of the sunset is reflected more in the water and the background is lightened by the sunset colors (rather than darkened by the grey/black clouds) so you see the outlines of the cays & other islands.

I agree with 1 of the posters though that if you cropped the forward part a bit, it would enhance that picture.

Both of them brought an 'ahhh' to my lips...