Thanks to all for your help and insight. The choice is hard but the waiting will indeed be the hardest part...

You're correct - Great Cruz Bay - Thanks

Hi. We're (2 adults plus a 17 year old boy and a 13 year old girl) already planning a 2015 trip to St. John. This is our first trip to St John and the trip will be more than our normal vacation budget so want to make sure we are doing it right.. :) Not sure how far in advance we need to book in orde...