We have stayed in many different villas over the years and are going for our second year to Southern Cross. The villa is beautiful, located in Chocolate Hole only a few minutes to Cruz Bay. Two interior rooms off of the great room work out well with children but it is still very private. Great pool ...

Have you tried VRBO.com? You can filter villas available by date and you deal directly with the owners or the management company they choose. I used to rent from Caribbean Villas but had a very bad experience a few years ago. We will be there last week in April-yay! Good luck with your search!

Thank you everyone for your input. It sounds like traveling during the week is better:) Can't wait to get back to the island in April.

We have always travel to St John Sat- Sat but decided to stay longer and travel Wednesday to Thursday in April. Is it generally less busy at the airport, ferries when traveling during the week? I appreciate any input !