I've never used them but their site and price kept popping up on a recent trip I was researching on kayak.com. Their price appears very low because it does not include certain airline fees (you don't see the actual total until the final booking page). The total was almost always within $10 of Pricel...

We stayed at Cocolobo in 2005. I would not recommend it for two couples for the same reason - the bedrooms are not even close to equal. Other positives: gorgeous views, quiet, few neighbors (at least in 2005, it was the last house on the road out to Reef Bay). Renting from Caribbean Villa was fine. ...