Hi Bob, I didn't know there was more than one Buck Island! The one I was considering was near St. Croix. We would first need to get to St. Croix and then find a way to Buck. Perhaps we will rent a dinghy this time and get ourselves a little further out from St. John. Thanks for your input - Molly

It's so good to see this forum is still alive! I found the forum invaluable five years ago when planning our first visit to StJ to celebrate our 10th anniversary. We are so excited to be heading back for our 15th anniversary in May! We spent our entire first trip (eight days) to StJ snorkeling much ...