A fun thing I used to take all my visitors on was the Nat. Park-sponsored Reef Bay Trail Hike....but you only hike DOWN hill, and then a snorkle boat picks you up and you get a boat ride back to Cruz Bay. Just go to or call the Nat. Park Headquarters for reservations.

I saw your post and scrolled down waiting for someone to suggest Windwardside and then it was YOU who found it! First a disclaimer: the owners are very good friends of mine and I used to work at the villa. However, I highly recommend it because they only own that and another cottage. It is not a gia...