We are leaving for St. John in May and I can't decide where to stay!!! Summerwind looks amazing and it has gotten great reviews...Villa Madeline and Sundance are very resonable...Is one better then the other?

I am new to the forum and we have reserved Summerwind 5/1/2010-5/7/2010 through Caribbean Villas. I didn't find much in the way of reveiws...so I wanted to see if anyone had info. The process of selecting a villa has been stressful and I am not sure I picked the right one!!! Help!