Thanks everyone for the suggestions. All the villas you listed looked great. Some were unavailable unfortunately. We ended up booking Miles Away. It looks really nice and I like that it has an alarm and is immaculate!

Thanks!

Thanks everyone for all your help! I will let you know what we ended up going with.

It is for 2 couples so no kids. We are looking to pay around $3500. We do want AC and would like to be somewhat close to Cruz Bay. I don't care if it's secluded or not, just as long as it's clean and safe.

We are planning our 1st trip to St John in April 2010. We want something that's clean, nice, and safe. Kind of nervous renting a house since we've never been before. We want 2 bedrooms and a pool.

Thanks in advance!