We have frequently used St. John Car Rental as well, but just found out that they have changed their in season date from December 14 to November 14, making our early December rental at high season rates. Going to try L&L - they have been very responsive so far.

We toured this villa in December as we were staying just above it and thought it might work for a larger group. It is a very, very nice house. Bright, vivid colors and a great open air feeling. The bedrooms offer a lot of sleeping arrangement options for an extended family. Super clean - we were the...

There has been discussion about Palm Hill on this and the Trip Advisor forum. You should take a look at them. The master bedroom is very spacious and has a nice shower, but there is still massive construction just below this house which disrupts the otherwise beautiful view. Although we also enjoyed...

The views are spectacular, but the landscape is pretty rugged and there isn't much vegetation. I personally don't think of it as a romantic spot. I have some photos of a June trip, including one looking back towards Concordia. Send me a private message if you want to see them.

We stayed at Sea Cruz (Island Getaways)in June and will return there in December. It is on Contant (close, but still removed from Cruz Bay), has a lovely pool and is perfect for two people. It has a spectacular view. See my villa review from our June trip.