The only thing that concerns me about La Papaya is it seems that the 2 bedrooms in the guest house are full sized beds and I'm not sure that anyone is going to want to suck it up and downgrade in bed size for their vacation.

Vistaero was actually our first choice, however it is not available for the weeks that all four couples are! It looks beautiful and we are bummed that we can't stay there.

Hey all. We are stuck on figuring out which villa we'd like to rent in August. There are 4 couples and we'd like to stay close to Cruz Bay. We're deciding between:
La Papaya
Ciellodonna
Beija Flor
Southern Cross
Any reviews or suggestions?