10 more days in paradise--the full report
Posted: Tue Mar 21, 2017 1:36 pm
John and I are back from a lovely 10 day visit to St. John. We split our stay between Caneel Bay and Gallows Point. It was a quiet trip for us, with less exploring around the island, less snorkeling (the water feels too cold to me in the winter), less time on the North Shore thanks to swells that persisted for much of our visit, lots more quiet time relaxing and reading, and LOTS of eating out. Here are some highlights.
Thursday March 3
Arrival at Caneel Bay

Dinner was something forgettable from the Beach Terrace. No pictures.
Friday March 4
The view from our room

Scott Beach

Our spot on the beach each day

Donkeys on the way to dinner

Dinner at Zozos

Lobster carbonara

Cured salmon pasta

Striped bass

Jumbo shrimp with fava bean puree


Saturday March 5
Flowers at Caneel Bay

We skipped the Caneel breakfast buffet and opted to split a turkey brie panino from the coffee shop at the resort. After I ordered the sandwich, the chef brought out gorgeous looking deep dish quiches. That’s what I am getting next time!
Breakfast on the deck of our room

Our daily spot. You might notice that there are no other chairs nearby. That may or may not be because we were always the first ones on the beach and we moved all of the other chairs out of our spot

Scott to Caneel snorkel
Southern stingray with jack

Strange raft. Caneel offers free rafts for their guests, but one man had brought along this large inflatable raft. I have never seen anything like it!

Flounder

Stoplight parrotfish

Trunkfish

Purple anemone

Juvenile yellowtail damselfish

Coney with moray eel

Turtle

Corals
[/
We had lunch at the Caneel Sushi Bar
Yellowtail koi

Tuna Island salad

Caneel Crunch roll

Sandy Beach roll

Donkeys

Sunset

Dinner was at Turtle Bay Estate House. It was too dark to take pictures by the time most of our food came. There was a fantastic breeze coming through the restaurant that night.
Bread service

Conch chowder

Sunday March 6

We checked out of Caneel and moved over to Gallows Point. I love Caneel but prefer more space after a few days. We had an ocean upper unit at Gallows, which gives you 1.5 baths, a galley kitchen, a living/dining room, and a lofted separate sleeping space. The units have central air but we never use it. I love the breeze through the louvers and the sound of the ocean (the sound of the ferry less so, but it’s not too bothersome).
The view from our Gallows unit

It started pouring around 5, so no sunset. We borrowed an umbrella from the front desk and headed to dinner at Rhumblines


Summer rolls

Pupu shrimp

Blackened scallops

Tuna with puff daddy noodles

Monday March 7
It was still raining off and on, but at least we had a rainbow. We spent the morning reading.

Eventually there was a break in the rain, so we went to lunch at the Lime Inn
Cracked conch

Snapper sandwich with pickled cauliflower salad

And with Josephine’s greens salad

More rain moved in that afternoon so we scrapped any beach plans and resumed our spots on the couches to read books until it was time for dinner at Extra Virgin Bistro
Drinks

Housemade ricotta with truffled corn

Crab cakes

Shrimp and crab papparadelle

Tuesday March 8
We drove over to Hansen Bay with the thought of snorkeling Pelican Rock

Not happening! It was FREEZING over there. I was wrapped up in beach towels and still shivering. We packed it in after an hour or so, and headed to lunch at Shipwreck Landing
Blackened shrimp

Fish reuben

Tuna tacos

It warmed up a bit in the afternoon so we snorkeled Gallows to Frank Bay
Orangespotted filefish


Moray eel

grouper

Sort-of sunset

Later that evening we went to dinner at Ocean’s 362
Drinks

Bread service

Local tomato salad

Tuna tartare with plantain chips and whipped feta

Vegetarian plate of farro with roasted root vegetables and feta

Roasted mahi and Caribbean lobster tail. This came with a kale that was one of my favorite things that we ate the entire vacation!

Wednesday March 9
We were feeling lazy, so we just spent the day reading books.
Eventually we rousted ourselves out of the condo and went for a drive. We stopped in for a snack at Aqua Bistro
Mahi mahi skewers

Tempura shrimp with wasabi cream

There was not much of a sunset due to the weather, but I thought the sky looked pretty

Thursday March 10
We went to breakfast at High Tide. The classic breakfast

Florentine benedict

Rainbow on Cruz Bay from High Tide

On the way back to Gallows we stopped to view the Club Med 2 anchored off of Cruz Bay

We snorkeled off Gallows to Frank Bay again.
Baby jacks

A well-hidden flounder

Blue tang

Angelfish

Orangespotted filefish

Needlefish

We went over to Trunk in the late afternoon and swam for a couple of hours. This became a routine of sorts for us. I think we visited Trunk four times this trip, always in the later afternoon after the crowds had left.
Club Med 2 leaving during sunset

That night we stopped by Drink! St. John for a cocktail. This place was never crowded any time we went by. I hope they are still in business this summer, as we finally got enough punches in our years-old loyalty card to get a free drink.


We had dinner at La Tapa
Langoustines

Bacalao fritters

Papparadelle with shrimp, langoustines and arugula in an albarino cream sauce

Tuna with crispy polenta

Friday March 10
Had another relaxing morning at Gallows and then went to lunch with friends at Cruz Bay Landing. No pictures this time, but everything was tasty. We swam at Trunk again in the afternoon.
That night we returned to Zozos for a second fantastic dinner.


Scallops Rockefeller

Tortellini in parmesean brodo

Pistachio crusted mahi mahi

Oven roasted fluke stuffed with crab


Saturday March 11
We got to Maho around 9:30. Read for a while and when it warmed up a bit we went snorkeling. Maho Bay was turtle town! We counted 14 different turtles, including one that was bigger than me.







Happy parrotfish!



Southern stingray

Peacock flounder

Sand diver

Lobster

Porkfish

Grouper

Octopus. We swam with this guy for over 20 minutes. I have over 40 photos of him. Here are five.





Needlefish

We tried to go to Miss Lucy’s for lunch but they were closed as they had hosted their full moon party the night prior. I did not realize that the parties are not always on the actual full moon date. Hopefully they will be open when we return this summer because I sorely missed their grouper reuben! We ended up having lunch at Aqua Bistro. Calamari

Fish tacos

We spent the afternoon at Trunk again.
Sunset


We went to the Terrace for dinner.
Drinks

Tuna tartare (this was excellent)

Roasted tomato tart

Tuna

Lobster

Camembert fritters

Sunday March 12
We decided to take an overlook tour since it had been some years since we stopped at the overlooks for photos. Caneel Bay

Trunk Bay

Maho and Francis Bays

We then decided to do the Leinster drift snorkel. The coral looked good but there were not as many fish as we are used to seeing here.


We returned to Shipwreck Landing for lunch

conch fritters

blackened shrimp quesadilla

Grouper sandwich

We went to Trunk…again
Sunday sunset

Kekoa at sunset

We were supposed to go to Asolare for dinner, as is tradition for our last night, but my stomach could not take another huge dinner, so we cancelled. Instead we went to the Beach Bar and split a couple of things

Tuna down now

Mahi tacos

Monday March 13
We checked out of Gallows and headed back to Caneel for lunch and the ferry to the airport. View from the upper terrace

Yellowtail koi

Crab and tuna wontons

Tuna tataki

Tuna island salad

And then it was time to go. Departure ferry

The saddest sight

We are booked for two weeks this summer, and have a much more adventurous trip planned, including two boat days. But for right now, this simple and unexciting trip was just what we wanted. Thanks for reading.
John and Becky

Thursday March 3
Arrival at Caneel Bay

Dinner was something forgettable from the Beach Terrace. No pictures.
Friday March 4
The view from our room

Scott Beach

Our spot on the beach each day

Donkeys on the way to dinner

Dinner at Zozos

Lobster carbonara

Cured salmon pasta

Striped bass

Jumbo shrimp with fava bean puree


Saturday March 5
Flowers at Caneel Bay

We skipped the Caneel breakfast buffet and opted to split a turkey brie panino from the coffee shop at the resort. After I ordered the sandwich, the chef brought out gorgeous looking deep dish quiches. That’s what I am getting next time!
Breakfast on the deck of our room

Our daily spot. You might notice that there are no other chairs nearby. That may or may not be because we were always the first ones on the beach and we moved all of the other chairs out of our spot


Scott to Caneel snorkel
Southern stingray with jack

Strange raft. Caneel offers free rafts for their guests, but one man had brought along this large inflatable raft. I have never seen anything like it!

Flounder

Stoplight parrotfish

Trunkfish

Purple anemone

Juvenile yellowtail damselfish

Coney with moray eel

Turtle

Corals

We had lunch at the Caneel Sushi Bar
Yellowtail koi

Tuna Island salad

Caneel Crunch roll

Sandy Beach roll

Donkeys

Sunset

Dinner was at Turtle Bay Estate House. It was too dark to take pictures by the time most of our food came. There was a fantastic breeze coming through the restaurant that night.
Bread service

Conch chowder

Sunday March 6

We checked out of Caneel and moved over to Gallows Point. I love Caneel but prefer more space after a few days. We had an ocean upper unit at Gallows, which gives you 1.5 baths, a galley kitchen, a living/dining room, and a lofted separate sleeping space. The units have central air but we never use it. I love the breeze through the louvers and the sound of the ocean (the sound of the ferry less so, but it’s not too bothersome).
The view from our Gallows unit

It started pouring around 5, so no sunset. We borrowed an umbrella from the front desk and headed to dinner at Rhumblines


Summer rolls

Pupu shrimp

Blackened scallops

Tuna with puff daddy noodles

Monday March 7
It was still raining off and on, but at least we had a rainbow. We spent the morning reading.

Eventually there was a break in the rain, so we went to lunch at the Lime Inn
Cracked conch

Snapper sandwich with pickled cauliflower salad

And with Josephine’s greens salad

More rain moved in that afternoon so we scrapped any beach plans and resumed our spots on the couches to read books until it was time for dinner at Extra Virgin Bistro
Drinks

Housemade ricotta with truffled corn

Crab cakes

Shrimp and crab papparadelle

Tuesday March 8
We drove over to Hansen Bay with the thought of snorkeling Pelican Rock

Not happening! It was FREEZING over there. I was wrapped up in beach towels and still shivering. We packed it in after an hour or so, and headed to lunch at Shipwreck Landing
Blackened shrimp

Fish reuben

Tuna tacos

It warmed up a bit in the afternoon so we snorkeled Gallows to Frank Bay
Orangespotted filefish


Moray eel

grouper

Sort-of sunset

Later that evening we went to dinner at Ocean’s 362
Drinks

Bread service

Local tomato salad

Tuna tartare with plantain chips and whipped feta

Vegetarian plate of farro with roasted root vegetables and feta

Roasted mahi and Caribbean lobster tail. This came with a kale that was one of my favorite things that we ate the entire vacation!

Wednesday March 9
We were feeling lazy, so we just spent the day reading books.
Eventually we rousted ourselves out of the condo and went for a drive. We stopped in for a snack at Aqua Bistro
Mahi mahi skewers

Tempura shrimp with wasabi cream

There was not much of a sunset due to the weather, but I thought the sky looked pretty

Thursday March 10
We went to breakfast at High Tide. The classic breakfast

Florentine benedict

Rainbow on Cruz Bay from High Tide

On the way back to Gallows we stopped to view the Club Med 2 anchored off of Cruz Bay

We snorkeled off Gallows to Frank Bay again.
Baby jacks

A well-hidden flounder

Blue tang

Angelfish

Orangespotted filefish

Needlefish

We went over to Trunk in the late afternoon and swam for a couple of hours. This became a routine of sorts for us. I think we visited Trunk four times this trip, always in the later afternoon after the crowds had left.
Club Med 2 leaving during sunset

That night we stopped by Drink! St. John for a cocktail. This place was never crowded any time we went by. I hope they are still in business this summer, as we finally got enough punches in our years-old loyalty card to get a free drink.


We had dinner at La Tapa
Langoustines

Bacalao fritters

Papparadelle with shrimp, langoustines and arugula in an albarino cream sauce

Tuna with crispy polenta

Friday March 10
Had another relaxing morning at Gallows and then went to lunch with friends at Cruz Bay Landing. No pictures this time, but everything was tasty. We swam at Trunk again in the afternoon.
That night we returned to Zozos for a second fantastic dinner.


Scallops Rockefeller

Tortellini in parmesean brodo

Pistachio crusted mahi mahi

Oven roasted fluke stuffed with crab


Saturday March 11
We got to Maho around 9:30. Read for a while and when it warmed up a bit we went snorkeling. Maho Bay was turtle town! We counted 14 different turtles, including one that was bigger than me.







Happy parrotfish!



Southern stingray

Peacock flounder

Sand diver

Lobster

Porkfish

Grouper

Octopus. We swam with this guy for over 20 minutes. I have over 40 photos of him. Here are five.





Needlefish

We tried to go to Miss Lucy’s for lunch but they were closed as they had hosted their full moon party the night prior. I did not realize that the parties are not always on the actual full moon date. Hopefully they will be open when we return this summer because I sorely missed their grouper reuben! We ended up having lunch at Aqua Bistro. Calamari

Fish tacos

We spent the afternoon at Trunk again.
Sunset


We went to the Terrace for dinner.
Drinks

Tuna tartare (this was excellent)

Roasted tomato tart

Tuna

Lobster

Camembert fritters

Sunday March 12
We decided to take an overlook tour since it had been some years since we stopped at the overlooks for photos. Caneel Bay

Trunk Bay

Maho and Francis Bays

We then decided to do the Leinster drift snorkel. The coral looked good but there were not as many fish as we are used to seeing here.


We returned to Shipwreck Landing for lunch

conch fritters

blackened shrimp quesadilla

Grouper sandwich

We went to Trunk…again
Sunday sunset

Kekoa at sunset

We were supposed to go to Asolare for dinner, as is tradition for our last night, but my stomach could not take another huge dinner, so we cancelled. Instead we went to the Beach Bar and split a couple of things

Tuna down now

Mahi tacos

Monday March 13
We checked out of Gallows and headed back to Caneel for lunch and the ferry to the airport. View from the upper terrace

Yellowtail koi

Crab and tuna wontons

Tuna tataki

Tuna island salad

And then it was time to go. Departure ferry

The saddest sight

We are booked for two weeks this summer, and have a much more adventurous trip planned, including two boat days. But for right now, this simple and unexciting trip was just what we wanted. Thanks for reading.
John and Becky
