Peachie's been lurking for a couple of years and we decided to get our feet wet
We'll be back "home" on St. John in 10 days 18 hours and...well, you get the idea. We simply love the place and this is our fifth return.
We're generally a pair of beach bums, snorkeling and sunning through the days and just kicking back over good food and some drinks at night. Being verrrry relaxed is our mantra.
Here's a go at our likes/not so likes
Under rated:
Estate Concordia studios. We've stayed here 4 times and always loved the privacy, cleanliness, the pool at the end of the day followed by pina coladas on the deck as we gaze at the stars and lights far out at sea. The price is very reasonable.
The Pavillion at Maho Bay - very good prices and generally great meals. Friday night is prime rib night, BTW.
Renting a car from Avis on STT - friendly service (unlike Budget) and better prices than on STJ.
Water Lemon Cay for snorkeling - simply beautiful, and the hike in keeps away the crowds.
Maho - yes, that Maho! Our first taste of paradise, so we're sentimental, but we enjoy the occasional convenience of just driving up and jumping in.
All the other beaches - simply an incredible place. Just avoid Trunk Bay during "cruise people" invasions; make this a last dip of the day around 3-4 PM.
The schooner Heron -Based in Rockport, Maine (we long admired the Heron on vacations there), Captain Twig and wife Bonnie built this gorgeous craft and certainly know their way about boats. Taking the sunset sail followed by dinner and "refreshments" at the Pavilion with fellow passengers last year, we found ourselves with fast friends as the sun dipped down. Based at Little Maho Bay last season.
Love City Mini Mart - if staying near Coral Bay , a convenient place to shop for food/beer/rum. Nothing fancy, just friendly and reasonable.
Over Rated:
Miss Lucy's: Same full moon dinner experience as others, 'nuf said.
Cruz Bay - just too busy for our tastes (we're pretty laid back). But this year we're staying at Serendip (we didn't reserve early enough at Concordia), so maybe we'll see it in a new light.
STT - overbuilt, kind of run down and we just haven't found it to be all that friendly. Also, cruise ship (oversized people barges?) mania - ick. A different world than STJ.
Oh yeah, and we'll chime in for Pia - we cannot imagine sharing our precious moments on romantic STJ with a crowd of people who clearly don't get it.
And thanks for all the new tips!